Just_ErikaEnter Shop
Platform Comparison

All Things Worn vs Pantydeal

All Things Worn and Pantydeal are two of the biggest names when people search for where to buy used panties. Both are large marketplaces with thousands of sellers, but they differ on fees, buyer protection and how transactions are handled. Here is an honest, side-by-side breakdown.

All Things Worn
Marketplace · since 2015
★★★★☆
  • Free sign-up to browse, large active community
  • No selling fee — sellers keep 100% of profit
  • Detailed listings with photos and seller reviews
  • Premium membership unlocks unlimited messaging/listings
  • Sellers must pay a recurring membership to sell
  • Quality varies widely across many independent sellers
  • Buyer must vet individual sellers themselves
Pantydeal
Marketplace · since 2012
★★★☆☆
  • One of the largest used-panty marketplaces (since 2012)
  • Sellers keep 100% — no per-sale commission
  • Buyers can join for free
  • Big catalog with chat rooms and message boards
  • Transactions are off-site, so the platform offers no buyer protection
  • Recurring reports of scammers and fake profiles
  • Complaints about unresponsive support and deleted accounts
At a glanceAll Things WornPantydeal
TypeMarketplaceMarketplace
Launched20152012
Seller fee≈ $15.99 / mo Premium Seller, or $69.99 / 6 months≈ $24.99 / 3 months or $44.99 / 6 months (seller membership)
Per-sale commission0% — no selling fee, keep 100% of profits0% — sellers keep 100% of sales
PaymentsSeller-arranged / on-platform messagingOff-site & buyer-arranged (CashApp, PayPal, gift cards)
VerificationAccount + community-driven reviewsLight; frequent reports of scammers
ShippingSeller-arranged, detailed listingsSeller-arranged
Best forBuyers who want a large fetish marketplace with detailed listings and reviewsBuyers who want the largest catalog and are comfortable vetting sellers themselves
Rating
★★★★☆
★★★☆☆

The verdict

All Things Worn edges out Pantydeal for most buyers thanks to detailed listings, a seller-review system and a free browsing tier. Pantydeal wins on sheer catalog size and history, but its fully off-site transactions mean no buyer protection. If you would rather skip vetting anonymous sellers entirely, buying direct from a single verified creator removes the guesswork.

Prefer one creator you can actually trust?

Skip the anonymous marketplaces and fake profiles. Buy direct from Just_Erika — verified, discreet, and consistent on every order.

Shop Used PantiesCustom Orders

Frequently asked questions

Every order ships in plain, unbranded packaging with no mention of the contents on the outside. The return label uses a neutral name, items are vacuum-sealed to protect freshness and privacy, and nothing on the parcel indicates what is inside. Your purchase stays completely private from doorstep to delivery.
Checkout is handled securely and discreetly. Charges appear neutrally and never describe the contents of your order. Unlike open marketplaces where buyers and sellers arrange payment off-site, ordering direct means a single, straightforward checkout with the creator you are actually buying from.
Each item is vacuum-sealed to lock in freshness, then placed inside plain, opaque packaging with no branding or description on the outside. This keeps your order private and preserves the condition of every piece in transit.

Sources

Fees and policies were verified in June 2026 and can change — always confirm on the platform directly.

Keep comparing

Pantydeal vs Sofia GraySnifffr vs All Things WornThe Best Pantydeal AlternativesThe Best Used Panties WebsitesIs All Things Worn Legit?Is Pantydeal Worth It?

Shop

Compare & Reviews

Latest Guides

Popular Questions